Metal Tokenization: What Digital Twins of Stocks Change in the Double-Pledging Problem, and What Remains Outside the Registry. Part 1.
Metal tokenization solves only one half of the double-pledging problem: a unified registry makes multiple claims on a single lot technically impossible, but it cannot confirm that the metal inside the bags actually exists. The Qingdao and Rotterdam cases show why accounting and physical control require different instruments.


For banks financing traders against warehouse stocks of metal, there is a double-pledging problem. The bank does not see the metal; it sees only a document:
a warehouse receipt;
an exchange warrant;
a registry statement.
If several receipts have been issued for the same lot, or a receipt has been issued for metal that is not in the warehouse, the collateral becomes a fiction. There are two ways in which this materializes:
multiple claims on a single lot — a matter of accounting and priority;
absence or substitution of the metal itself — a matter of physical control.
Losses from such schemes can be significant. An example is the June 2014 case at the Chinese port of Qingdao. According to the verdict of the Intermediate People's Court of Qingdao dated 10 December 2018, the company Dezheng Resources and its actual controller Chen Jihong organized a systematic scheme between November 2012 and May 2014.
Company employees forged warehouse certificates for aluminum, alumina and electrolytic copper, including documents of Qingdao Port Group and Yantai Port Group. They then used them to obtain loans, letters of credit and acceptances from banks by re-pledging the same lots of goods.
The court established that the total volume of funds obtained through fraud against counterparties amounted to more than RMB 12.3 billion. Separately, through re-pledging and forged documents, the company obtained loans, letters of credit and acceptances from 13 banks totaling more than RMB 3.6 billion.
Second case: according to London Metal Exchange notice 23/044 of 17 March 2023, cited by Reuters, it received information about irregularities in several shipments of physical nickel from one warehouse of a licensed operator.
Following an inspection carried out by the warehouse operator, nine nickel warrants were invalidated — they accounted for 0.14% of the active nickel stocks under warrants. The exchange asked all licensed warehouses to re-check nickel under warrants and reminded them of the strict requirement to weigh all metal before registering a warrant.
According to a Bloomberg report citing operator Access World, the warehouse in question was in Rotterdam, and the contents of the bags were stones, not nickel. According to the publication's calculations, 9 warrants correspond to approximately 54 tonnes of metal.
Separately, according to London Metal Exchange disciplinary notice of 1 April 2025, Access World Vlissingen B.V. agreed to pay a fine of GBP 60 thousand. Between 18 October and 16 November 2022, four warrants for nickel cathodes were mistakenly discharged from the Warehouse Italy facility at the company's Rotterdam division. The exchange learned of this incident only on 14 March 2023 — approximately five months after it occurred.
How double pledging arises?
Double pledging is the issuance of multiple claims on a single lot of metal or the use of one document to obtain financing from several creditors.
The first type of failure is multiple claims on a single lot. Metal is stored in a warehouse, the warehouse issues a receipt. The trader presents it to Bank A and obtains a loan. The same metal may be documented by a receipt from another warehouse, or the same receipt may be presented to Bank B. As long as banks do not exchange data and the warehouse does not maintain a public record of encumbrances, double pledging remains invisible.
The second type is absence or substitution of metal. A receipt may be issued for metal that has already been removed, or for contents that do not match what is declared.
Conditions under which double-pledging schemes work:
each bank sees only its own receipt;
the warehouse is not obliged to report the existence of other encumbrances;
there is no unified registry with legal priority;
paper documents are used, which are easy to forge, although electronic ones do not provide full protection either;
the metal is stored outside the exchange system;
there is collusion with the warehouse operator.
Different types of failure require different means of protection:
1. Multiple claims on a single lot is a problem of accounting and priority. It is closed by a unified registry that makes encumbrances visible and technically prevents the issuance of a second receipt for the same lot.
2. Absence or substitution of metal is a problem of physical control: it is not closed by either a paper or an electronic document, because the record confirms a right, not the contents of the bag. Inspections, weighing and analysis are required.
The registry and physical verification solve different tasks and do not replace each other. Metal tokenization closes the first type of failure and does not close the second. For more on the tokenized assets market, see another material in our blog.
What a digital twin of a stock and a token are
A record of metal is a digital description of a specific lot: who the producer is, what the brand is, the melt number, how much it weighs, what the analysis shows, where it is stored. This is a digital twin of the stock in the narrow sense: not the metal itself, but its description in the system.
A record of a receipt is a document issued by the warehouse that confirms that the holder has a right to the metal. If the warehouse operates outside the exchange system, there are no unified standards for such a receipt — each warehouse formats it in its own way.
A record of a pledge right is a separate record that the metal is pledged to a creditor and where that creditor stands in the order of claims relative to others. This is an independent legal regime: it can exist regardless of the form in which the receipt is drawn up.
A token is a transferable representation of a right. Depending on how it is structured, it can represent any of these three records: a description of the metal, a receipt, or a pledge right.
London Metal Exchange (LME) electronic warrants appeared on 1 March 2021. The venue fully switched to electronic form of documents. However, this did not prevent the substitution of nickel in Rotterdam. The electronic warrant confirmed the holder's right to the metal within the exchange's system, but did not confirm that the bags actually contained nickel.
What problems the registry actually solves
1. The registry establishes a strict correspondence: one lot — one valid receipt — one encumbrance. Within the registry this formula is implemented technically: the system will not allow a second receipt to be issued for a lot that already has an active encumbrance on record.
Double pledging becomes not a question of the participants' good faith but technically impossible within the system: the registry will not allow a second receipt to be issued for a lot that already has an active encumbrance on record.
2. The history of transfers of the receipt is transparent, and the encumbrance is released when the warehouse reflects the disposal. This closes the gap that in the traditional scheme arises between the physical movement of goods and the updating of records at each creditor: until the bank receives notification, the pledge continues to be recorded in its system.
But the registry learns of the disposal of metal only when the warehouse enters the corresponding record, and not automatically upon physical movement of the cargo. For the registry to work effectively, two conditions must be met:
The registry must be legally determinative for pledge priority — the order of claims is established by a record in the system, not by the date of signing a paper contract;
It must be mandatory for all documents on a given lot. If a parallel paper document remains valid outside the system — for example, one issued in another jurisdiction — the registry protects only those who use it and leaves a loophole for the rest.
Existing systems show how these conditions are implemented in practice.
China's "National Center for the Registration of Commodity Warehouse Receipts" registry was launched in July 2026. According to the official publication of the Office of the Financial Committee of the Shanghai Municipal Committee of the CPC, the first transactions were conducted with nickel and copper on the state-owned Hangmaolian blockchain infrastructure.
This is an operating system. The platform covers the full cycle: issuance, registration, transfer and redemption of receipts.
According to statements by the platform operator:
the blockchain receipt is created on-chain from the moment of issuance, not after the paper is drawn up;
warehouse data are synchronized;
ownership, quantity and storage location are recorded on the blockchain.
According to the statement of the National Registration Center, this reduces the risks of double pledging, forged receipts and selling the same goods to several buyers. These formulations reflect the operator's position, not an independent assessment.
Scale, according to the operator's data as of May 2026:
more than 277 thousand tonnes of goods have been registered at the National Registration Center;
the total value of registered receipts is about RMB 140 million;
the value of stocks is RMB 26.2 billion.
A pilot financing program with Zheshang Bank covered 993 tonnes of pledged goods worth more than RMB 100 million. An earlier copper financing initiative allowed companies to raise RMB 17.4 million through fully digital channels. Requirements for digital warehouse receipts come into force on 1 September 2026.
Limitation. As noted in the operator's materials, the blockchain registry does not conduct an independent verification of the physical presence of goods in the warehouse. Records on the chain confirm the uniqueness of rights, but not the contents of the bags.
Singapore in 2021 amended the Electronic Transactions Act, incorporating the UNCITRAL provisions on electronic transferable records. Electronic warehouse receipts are now legally recognized as equivalent to paper ones — provided there is reliable identification of the record and exclusive control over it.
Section 16Q of the law provides for the accreditation of providers, but, according to the response of the Ministry of Trade and Industry dated 12 January 2026, this mechanism has not been activated: "EnterpriseSG will consider the need for accreditation if and when sufficient market interest arises."
In practice, metals in Singapore are stored and financed through the London Metal Exchange ecosystem, whose banks accept the exchange's digital warrants.
Local receipts for non-exchange warehouses remain paper. As the Ministry of Trade and Industry of Singapore indicated in its response of 12 January 2026, companies choose off-exchange storage based on the cost or end use of the metal, and such warehouses issue paper receipts. They have no incentive to implement a separate digital platform."
The Gold Bar Integrity (GBI) Database of the London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) was launched in January 2025. It tracks the provenance of gold and its storage history in order to reduce the risk of metal from questionable sources and counterfeit bars entering the market.
The database combines two datasets:
Good Delivery List refiners upload information on country of origin and responsible sourcing;
London vaults enter data at the level of individual bars.
The platform was built by Swiss company aXedras on distributed ledger technology: a digital twin is created for each bar with a history of provenance and storage. Timeline:
launch — January 2025;
by the end of 2025, 98% of refiners were connected to the platform;
from 30 April 2026, reporting on country of origin is voluntary;
from 2027 — mandatory monthly.


